Kombo : : : PS3 | 360 | Wii | Cube | Xbox | PSP | DS | Forums | Podcasts

AROUND KOMBO:
BLOG
The Moody Gamer
Do you have gaming ADD?
The Golden Compass
Console
PlayStation 3
Publisher
Sega
Genre
Action
Developer
Shiny Entertainment
Release Date
12/04/07
4
ESRB Rating
Everyone
StumbleUpon Toolbar  
Posted by:
Ryan Olsen
Reviews Director
REVIEW
The Golden Compass
The Golden Compass is hopelessly lost.
December 23, 2007 | 10:51 AM PST

AMN's Review Policy: Our reviews are written for you. Our goal is to write honest, to-the-point reviews that don't waste your time. This is why we've split our reviews into four sections: What the Game's About, What's Hot, What's Not and Final Word, so that you can easily find the information you want from our reviews.

What the Game's About
The Golden Compass follows the story of the book and newly released motion picture. You play as Lyra Belacqua who is out to save her uncle. She isn't alone because she is accompanied by Pan, her animal daemon, and Iorek, an armor wearing polar bear. You explore different locals in the game that follows in the footsteps of the movie.

What's Hot
Fans of The Golden Compass are sure to recognize how the video game takes cues from the movie. Lyra, Iorek and the lot all look like their movie counter parts. Truth be told, The Golden Compass is a game aimed at youngsters. Children under 10 years old are sure to find a lot to enjoy in being a spunky young hero and a giant polar bear.

There are also some instances where you have to complete mini-games to progress. While there are many of the overused button timing sequences, some of the original mini-games, like when you first start trying to "deceive" others, actually break-up the action nicely. The pratfalls some of the enemies will take will give kids a chuckle here and there.

The musical score that plays in the background fits the feeling of the game nicely. The soundtrack is really the shining star of the game. Actual movie footage was a nice bonus to see.

What's Not
The Golden Compass falls where other game-movie tie-ins fall: the rush to meet an impossible deadline. It is obvious from the beginning that corners had to be cut and care was not taken with the license. The dialogue and script for the game is downright laughable, no emotion in the voice overs and the writing is plain bad. The sound effects "clink" and "clunk" their way through your speakers, which will have you cringe. When text appears on screen, often there will be a number of boxes overlapping to make the screen look like a jumbled mess.

Gameplay and control fall in the same trap. Platforming and exploration sections are cookie cutter affairs. Controlling the polar bear Iorek is like flying a dragon in Lair – large, unwieldy, and not fun, plus the combat is repetitive. The visuals were made for the lowest common denominator because it looks like a PS2 game with slightly better looking textures.

Final Word
The Golden Compass, the book, has received more critical praise than it can count. Unfortunately, the same doesn't hold true for the movie or the video game. The reason why the game didn't come out well is simple, movie-games usually forced to agree to an impossible deadline. Corners were cut everywhere and it shows. With a book so full of imagination, it is disappointing to see the game turn out the way it did. Youngsters are sure to thoroughly enjoy the game and not care or notice the negative aspects all that much. All they will care about is when can they beat up more wolves as Iorek.
Visuals
Some of the texturing on Iorek is decent but everything else is PS2 quality.
3.5
Sound
The orchestral score saves the title but everything else is not "sound."
6.5
Control
Slow, clunky controls but Lyra's portions aren't that bad.
4.5
Gameplay
Neat mini-game ideas but the cookie-cutter gameplay isn't even copied from the best in the adventure genre.
4.0
Lasting Appeal
Very little lasting value. You play it, then forget about it.
2.5
Verdict
Save for a few features that offer a little bit of hope, the rest of the game crushes the stilts it was built on. Children will find the game enjoyable, however.
4.0
[not an average]
Review Scores Guide
Screenshot Gallery

(Date Not Available)

(Date Not Available)

(Date Not Available)

Got something that we should post on the site? Send it to us!
February 8, 2010
Twenty more winners to go for our Game a Day Giveaway! Don't hesitate... enter today! Also, make sure you become a fan of Kombo on Facebook!!!

-- Ken Cauley, Editor in Chief

Kombo Breaker
FTW
Kombo's Game a Day Giveaway!
We're giving away a new game EVERYDAY throughout all of February!

Official Contest Page!

WINNERS:

  • February 2: John Riemer, Virgina
  • February 3: Jonathan Dowell, Pennsylvania
  • February 4: Chris Ryan, Florida
  • February 5: Chris Foster, Michigan
  • February 6: Adam Cuevas, Florida
  • February 7: Josh Minar, Kentucky
  • February 8: Bradley Mosbacher, Missouri
  • If SEGA made Shenmue 3, would it SELL?
    Vote!
    (02/09/10 | 12:41 PM PST)
    February's Xbox LIVE Marketplace Updates
    (02/09/10 | 12:21 PM PST)
    It May Be The End for Nippon Ichi Software
    (02/09/10 | 11:13 AM PST)
    Headaches and Sickness Induced by 3D
    (02/09/10 | 5:56 AM PST)
    HDTV vs. SNES
    DiRT 2!!!
  • DiRT 2 for Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3
    Enter to win!
    E-mail us and include your full name, age and mailing address to enter.

  • Software
    Hardware
    All Time
    Weekly
    9.89m Japan
    31.48m America
    25.90m Others
    67.28M 
    1.25m Japan
    21.76m America
    14.63m Others
    37.64M 
    4.74m Japan
    12.71m America
    14.31m Others
    31.76M 
    29.79m Japan
    44.83m America
    50.20m Others
    124.81M 
    14.02m Japan
    18.98m America
    20.85m Others
    53.85M